The Western Conveyancing Protocol provides a framework for handling certain real estate transactions in Western Canada. The Protocol and title insurance serve different purposes, and understanding that distinction is important when assessing the risks of a transaction.
The Western Conveyancing Protocol was designed to streamline the closing process by establishing procedures for transactions that fall within its scope. While it can provide efficiencies for lawyers, it applies only to the types of closings covered by the Protocol. It does not apply to every transaction or eliminate risks associated with the property or provide coverage for those risks.
Title insurance serves a different purpose in the transaction. Rather than establishing procedures, it provides coverage for specified risks that may affect the title or ownership. Unlike the Protocol, title insurance can be used across a range of real estate transactions, with coverage tailored to the particular risks of the deal through endorsements. This can be important when a transaction involves risks that may not be addressed through the closing process alone.
The Protocol’s exclusions also demonstrate the importance of understanding where it applies. New construction, for example, is excluded because these transactions can involve complexities that do not fit within the Protocol’s standardized closing framework. Builders’ liens, holdback requirements, and construction delays can create additional risks and priority issues. Title insurance will provide additional protection for transactions on properties excluded from the Protocol, such as new construction.
The Protocol is designed to facilitate transactions that fit within a well-defined and straightforward process. It is not intended to address every risk that may arise in a real estate transaction. Lawyers must consider not only whether a transaction can be completed efficiently using the Protocol, but also whether risks associated with the deal have been identified and addressed as part of their closing process.
Agricultural properties and multi-title transactions can introduce additional considerations that may not arise in a conventional residential transaction. Multiple parcels, different legal descriptions, access considerations, zoning or land-use issues, and other property-specific risks can require additional due diligence and, depending on the transaction, additional title insurance coverage.
This is where the flexibility of title insurance becomes relevant. While a standard title insurance policy provides coverage for specific risks, endorsements can be used to address additional risks or circumstances associated with a particular transaction.
The same principle applies when a transaction involves a known title issue. A known title defect does not simply disappear because the transaction closes. It must be identified and addressed as part of the risk assessment.
In certain circumstances, title insurance can address a known risk through the identified risk endorsement. The known title defect is described as an exception in Schedule B of the policy, while the endorsement provides coverage for the specified risk, subject to the terms and conditions of the policy and endorsement.
The Protocol provides a framework for completing a transaction, while title insurance provides a means of underwriting specified risks associated with the transaction. Where a known risk can be evaluated and underwritten, the identified risk endorsement may allow coverage to be provided for that specific exposure.
As Nitin Bhatia, K.C., founding partner of SB LLP in Edmonton, notes, “Title insurance remains an important risk-management tool, even for Protocol-eligible transactions, particularly where the nature of the property or transaction presents risks that cannot be adequately addressed through the standardized process.”
A real-world claim illustrates how this approach can work. In 2020, a family purchased a property knowing that its garage encroached on a municipal setback. The risk was assessed during underwriting, and coverage was provided through an owner’s policy with an identified risk endorsement covering the potential removal of the encroaching portion of the garage.
One year after closing, the municipality issued a formal notice requiring part of the garage to be removed. The resulting claim was approximately $132,000. Coverage was provided for the cost of removing the encroaching portion.
Risks can also emerge after closing that were not addressed as part of the transaction. In one Alberta claim, an entire septic system had been installed without the required municipal permit. After closing, the municipality identified the violation, and the homeowners were faced with the cost to bring the system into compliance. The resulting claim was approximately $136,000.
These claims illustrate how property-related risks can have significant financial consequences, whether a defect is known before closing or only discovered afterward. While the Western Conveyancing Protocol provides a framework for eligible transactions, it does not eliminate every risk associated with a property or address every circumstance in which title insurance may provide coverage. For legal professionals, understanding the scope and limitations of the Protocol and title insurance is essential to assessing the risks of a transaction and determining what protection may be appropriate for their clients.
To learn more about title insurance and how it can help manage risks in real estate transactions, visit chicagotitle.ca.
Chicago Title Insurance Company
Chicago Title has built an industry reputation for our unmatched claims-paying and underwriting abilities. With client success at the forefront of every transaction, our team knows how to put your needs first, offering an industry-leading, customized policy, and unmatched customer experience. Learn more about Chicago Title.
Nitin Bhatia, K.C., SB LLP Barristers & Solicitors
Nitin was born and raised in Edmonton and is a founding partner of SB LLP and Team Lead of the firm’s Real Estate Group. He maintains a multi-faceted transactional practice focused on corporate securities and banking matters, commercial real estate as well as residential real estate. Learn more about Nitin Bhatia, K.C.
This article is Sponsored Content.